Tax cap looks permanent


On Board Online • June 27, 2011

By Marc Humbert
Senior Writer

State government was poised to impose a tax cap on school districts and local governments as On Board went to press, and the fine print suggests the cap will be permanent.

The tax cap is part of a legislative deal in which Republicans from outside New York City, who control the state Senate, agreed to extend and somewhat expand the law that keeps rents on many apartments below open market rates in New York City. The city is home to the bulk of the state Assembly's Democratic majority.

Under provisions of a legislative package, rent control for New York City would remain in place for four years and the tax cap law would "sunset" after five years. But the agreement also called for the tax cap to remain in effect if the rent laws are again extended. That is considered a near-certainty, as the rent laws have been routinely extended every few years since World War II.

Gov. Andrew Cuomo and legislative leaders said there would be some mandate relief included, but details were sparse. Action is likely to be minimal; the governor said one of his own major mandate relief proposals – creation of a new pension tier for public employees - had been set aside for the time being.

There were reports that the final legislative package could include a provision allowing school districts to piggyback on purchasing contracts negotiated by other governmental agencies outside New York. That is a component of NYSSBA's "Playbook" for providing mandate relief to school districts.

(Editor’s note: Check www.nyssba.org for updates on final legislative action.)

In other state news:

  • The Legislature passed a NYSSBA-supported bill to standardize schools' responses when a student athlete suffers a concussion.
  • Legislative leaders and the governor agreed to raise tuition at the State University of New York campuses by $300 a year for the next five years.
  • The Legislature approved a measure that would increase penalties for those who promote or engage in prostitution near schools. That bill was prompted by a January report in The New York Times about a thriving prostitution business right outside a Bronx elementary school.
  • There was a bit of potential good fiscal news as state Comptroller Tom DiNapoli reported that state tax collections were running ahead of projections for the first two months of the new state fiscal year. But DiNapoli cautioned that "it's too soon to tell if this is a trend or an aberration."

Should tax collections continue to exceed projections that could make it easier for Cuomo and the Legislature to deliver on a pledge made this spring to increase state school aid as part of next year's state budget by at least $800 million. 

Tax cap opposed by NYSSBA, others

The tax cap has been opposed by NYSSBA and a host of other education and local government groups who have said it would tie the hands of local officials at a time of declining state support. More than $1 billion was cut from state school aid this year.

But Cuomo insisted the tax cap would help turn around the New York economy. "We are on the cusp of historic progress for this state," he said.

The local property tax cap, a key part of Cuomo's campaign agenda last year, would limit annual tax levy increases to 2 percent or the rate of inflation, whichever is less. It would apply to school budgets prepared for the 2012-13 school year.

Exempt from the cap would be employer pension contribution costs that are more than 2 percent above the previous year's level, court judgments that exceed 5 percent of a district's tax levy, and building project bond payments.

The tax cap could be exceeded with the approval of 60 percent or more of a school district's voters.

NYSSBA Executive Director Timothy G. Kremer said that if school districts are going to have to live with a tax cap, there needs to be meaningful relief from state-imposed mandates and costs over which districts have little control.

"If the state is giving districts less aid and limiting the amount that can be raised locally, school boards need the tools that can allow them to run schools more efficiently," said Kremer. "The alternative is to hurt the children and their education."




Back to top